a survey about audio quality in vids

So I'm making this vid, right, but the audio I was originally going to go with is the live version of the song. I own the recorded version (somewhere), and I would just as rather use an audio track that didn't have random people clapping and cheering in the middle of the song.

The problem is that there's a line of the song that is only in the audio version, and it's a line that will be PERFECT for a scene of the movie I'm working with.

What are your thoughts? Would you watch a vid that used a live version of a song? Or would that put you off?